

i wanted to make this short. but it was not possible for me.Please on ur free time read this completely. It may change ur views about GANDHI ,FATHER OF NATION.
dont think a Gandhivadi is writing that,truely i m not.
i only want to comment to some points related to GANDHI.
hope u heard "मज़बूरी का नाम महात्मा गाँधी ." i.e. "(helplessness) compulsion is Gandhi".
can u ask reason (मज़बूरी) to Gandhi of leaving the best income source work of a lawyer.
can u ask reason of giving up whole happy life for those people who dont even live in his country (S.A.).
can u ask reason for going jail, being hurt really a lot ,moving in whole country barefoot,doing fast (his best weapon) ,giving trouble ,pain to himself.
please try to feel his life .u cant even imagine how a human (specially a man) can do these things.lakhs of authors have written books,articles on him.how can he be a general person?how can he make millions (including Dalai Lama,Nelson Mandela)to follow him?
main objections on his life which i also sometimes feel correct:
# It was true he couldnt save SARDAR BHAGAT SINGH .(but see couldnt not didnt)
# He stopped "non cooperation movement" after violence in Chaura Chauri.(cant say anithing)
# He is supposed to be only leader who gave INDIA Freedom.(It's not his fault.He never said this)
# He is supposed to be responsible for division.
truly speaking he was not. but it was not Jinnah also.because if we think Jinnah as a nation maker it will be a big fault to give a credit of a nation (whatever it may be) to such a person who had nothing to do so.It was basicily english gov. and mistake of Indian (Congress) leaders to avoid the demand of new state in earlier stages and then name of Jinnah.
Chosing Nehru as his successor was his big fault.Nehru may be responsible for Independence (as i dont think so) but he was more or less responsible for almost all problems which INDIA faced before or after 1947.Division includes it.
# NETAJI SUBHASH,CHANDRASHEKHAR AAZAD,BHAGAT SINGH,couldnt get their proper respect due to Gandhi.
Completely incorrect.Gandhi never treated them as wrong but since he only considered nonviolence as a single way he never supported them.NETAJI himself treated Gandhiji the ideal for INA.NETAJI told many a times "Gandhiji is working for independence.We have to help them.If we could make this force during 'Quit India Movement' we can live in free air now".
a long after independence Nehru said "if Netaji will be alive we will file a suit against him and treat him as traitor as he made a force with enemy (Japan,Jermany) and attacked on India."
There r sure proofs that GREAT ARTICLES, THOUGHTS written by Bhagat Singh is misplaced (or whatever) by Nehru.Nehru was not happy with even IRON MAN SARDAR VALLABHBHAI PATEL who joined 565 states in INDIA (an impossible work).
#One more person LOKMANYA BAL GANGADHAR TILAK was there b4 Gandhi who has started all the things which were used by Gandhi,but Gandhi lived those things and made others to follow.
# Congess now work only on the name of GANDHI.
It may be respectfull for a person to be a symbol of a national party.But main thing, after Independence he wanted to coclude Congress, but it couldnt be possible.And one more problem ,most of great leaders who dont want a big post in gov. and wanted to work in ground level left the congress and then congress is working mostly on name of Gandhi Nehru family,but this Gandhi is not Mahatma Gandhi. there was an election between Son (or grandson)of Mahatma Gandhi (something like that,i forgot the name) and Rajiv Gandhi .It was called election between real and second (rajiv) gandhi. The result was lose of reality.
# He gave more support to Musalmans.
Not true.He considered both as same.***He walked barefooted village after village in Noakhali district of East Bengal, in a hostile atmosphere created by riots and made the people to take a pledge not to kill others. Where were those champions of Hindus who wanted them to retaliate?There were 'brave men' in India who from house tops were saying: "Hindus/Musalmans are being butchered, they are subjected to atrocities in Noakhali and other places and we must save them." But, there was only one Gandhi and his peace mission went to Noakhali.***
(copy of a person's thought,dont know whose)
a few comments on Lage raho munna bhai:
nice movie, nice way of representing BAPU'S PRINCIPALS.
(now just think a hero of bollywood movie faced a lot troubels how a REAL HERO had faced.)
movie only used Mahatma Gandhi to move a love story.Liquor which Gandhi protested a lot was well used by hero.People told in poll, presence of Gandhi made them bore while munna,circuit made them laugh.
Noble prize to Gandhiji:
Nirmala Deshpandey said"will u give nobel to Christ, Nanak or Buddha.Nobel is for general people.Gandhi is far above than this."
An eye for an eye makes the whole world blind.
--Mahatma Gandhi
Whatever you do will be insignificant, but it is very important that you do it.
--Mahatma Gandhi
Furthermore, Romain Rolland, a great man of the same Century said:
"Mahatma Gandhi is another Christ."
now at last please read this words of einstein again but this time use ur HEART with emotions;
"Generations to come…will scarcely believe that such a one as this even in
flesh and blood walked upon this earth."

amazing,brilliant and sensitive!!!...this is a post of its kind,keep it up rajat !!
ReplyDelete